FYI: I have two outside votes for #2...
Here's some back story: For Christmas I took #4 and blew it up to poster size as a present for Bill. The "problem" is that picture is in sepia tones. We still plan on framing that one, but I realized I can't hang it over the fireplace. All of our other pictures are in black and white, and even though it looks great in the sepia, I cannot bring myself to hang it.
As far as #2 & #3; I took one of them, Bill took the other.
Obviously the viewers choice is going to #3. We have a winner!
Bill is the proud picture taker! He's only gloated a little, that may change once we print it and hang it over the fireplace!
Thank you all for your input. It was a tough decision! I appreciate your help. As soon as we get it framed and hung, I'll post a picture. It will take awhile because there is painting to be done in the living room!!! Check back this summer... I'm not promising anything! Thanks again! You saved us.